A sharp decline in gold prices can shake confidence in even the strongest bull market. For Tavi Costa, the recent sell-off has done little to undermine his conviction that the long-term forces supporting gold remain intact.
Costa believes the market is underestimating the scale of the economic changes ahead and the growing importance of physical resources in an increasingly capital-intensive world. His outlook raises a compelling question:
Could the recent downturn be obscuring an investment cycle that has barely begun?
Read the transcript below.
Transcript
Tavi Costa
You don’t get bearish on gold after it’s down 30%. Like, if you believe that gold could be multiples from here and gold is down 30%, you take advantage of that. So that’s how I approach this.
Monetary Metals
Welcome back to The Gold Exchange Podcast. My name is Ben Nadelstein of Monetary Metals. I am joined by the one and only Tavi Costa. He is the CEO of Azuria Capital. And of course, if you’ve seen Tavi anywhere else, or if you’ve seen him on this podcast, you know, he is well known as a macro investor, known for his research on precious metals, commodities, emerging markets, and of course, long-term economic cycles. He joins the podcast today to talk through all of it. Tavi, welcome back to the show.
Tavi Costa
Thanks for having me, Ben. Looking forward to this.
Monetary Metals
Okay. When I saw what happened with the Brazilian elections, I already was planning on having you on. But then when I saw the shock result, I was like, oh my gosh, we need to have Tavi. But let’s save that for later into the interview. Keep our audience guessing. Let’s start with what’s going on with Azoria Capital. You’ve launched this fund. Tell us what is the kind of macro theme or the broader investment thesis that you guys are using?
How Tavi looks for upside in mining stocks
Tavi Costa
Thanks for having me. We just launched a mining-focused fund. Our plan is to be investing solely in this industry that I believe so much is at a level of relevance that is not in line with the market cap of the overall industry relative to global equity markets, which is about 1% and used to be double digits in prior eras. What we are seeing today in regards to the need for materials demand and the supply constraints is to me one of the biggest opportunities I’ve seen in my career.
I’ve been involved with this industry for some time now, and I want to expand that network and experience into launching this fund, which is going to have, or already has, about 60 to 65% exposure into silver companies specifically. And I’m very excited to be building this from scratch. I’m really excited especially because of this pullback that we’ve seen in the market. And the timing to me is very compelling as well.
Monetary Metals
What are some of the macro trends that you saw that made you think, wow, it is so compelling, I want to get into the space, when many big institutions, investment funds look at mining as kind of, well, why would we invest in mining? What in the mining sector and in this obviously commodity sector attracted you to it?
Tavi Costa
Back in the days I looked into, I was probably one of the first people to put this research together about capital spending in the commodity space. I look into the commodity space very broadly and realize that CapEx overall, when it’s at ultra-low levels, historically speaking, every time it marked the bottom for commodities and resource industries. And then the question becomes, what commodity should you invest if that’s the case? And learning more about how the timeline for going from exploration to production and bringing new supply into the space takes so much time naturally put me in a position of looking at metals and mining. And I think that metals and mining is still in that major imbalance that we’re seeing.
Obviously, the AI trend was not something that I foresee when I first started to invest in this industry, but a lot of things have sort of shaped in a way that have added to the case. For instance, the policy response after COVID, which we added about 40% of all the dollars we have in the system today, were added in that time. And, you know, that’s sort of, you know, almost like politicians basically showed their cards of what they’re willing to do, going above and beyond to make sure there’s enough liquidity in the system.
And now we have an excess of liquidity for the amount of hard assets we have. And so I think that, yes, we’re going to have some cyclicality and issues that are going to cause mid-cycle corrections like we’ve seen recently with the mining space, but the the big thesis here is much bigger than that.
It’s way bigger than that. And if we see onshoring, countries becoming less and less reliant on each other, trying to rebuild their manufacturing, rebuild their industries, and trying to also be in this kind of wartime spending for artificial intelligence and having to build data centers, you know, go beyond what’s happening just in the elections right now. All these things are just noise. If you take a much broader perspective, you know, we just haven’t seen anything.
And then you understand that this is much deeper than all that. I mean, the fact that there’s so inefficiencies in the mining industry, which is a code word for opportunity. And the main reason for it is because it’s such a complex industry and so technical that, you know, it creates a lot of not only imbalances but also mispriced opportunities. And so to me, you know, the money management industry that focuses so much on mining is very small.
All of us kind of know each other. In a lot of cases, we collaborate, we try to think collectively. And certainly, I think that this industry requires a bridge of knowledge to bring more capital back into the space to provide more liquidity to the right people in order to create the new discoveries, create the new supply that we need so much for society.
And I think that the same way that the issues between US and China became bipartisan not too long ago between Democrats and the Republicans, I think that the desperate need for materials is going to become also bipartisan because it’s at the core of the inflation problem. The more they realize that the inflation that we have in the system today is not only being created by the reckless spending that they have fiscally, but also by the issues that we have in regards to lack of supply.
So a big macro thesis is created exactly like that, is by looking at the big constraints that we have in the system where the debt imbalance is so large that will likely cause the system to be inflated its way out of the debt problem. And as we inflate our way out of the problem, we’re likely to see hard assets be appreciated much higher. And if you look at across the hard assets, there are many opportunities.
You know, you can look at emerging markets, one of the main things that I’m also very involved, or you can look at also into energy, you know, another space that I was very excited about months and months ago before the war, you know, maybe 12 months or so ago. And now obviously in a different place, but there’s going to be big themes that are going to come out of this hard assets idea. To me, that’s kind of at the core of my macro views and how I want to sort of expand these ideas over time, but mining is definitely one of them.
What AI infrastructure could mean for commodity demand
Monetary Metals
And how important is this idea of wartime spending on this AI train where we’re saying, listen, if we don’t spend the money on AI, China’s gonna spend the money on AI, so we better spend the money. It’s just like when we were in war, we threw money at chips, we’re gonna throw money at tanks, and now we’re gonna throw money at AI.
Do you think that basically because of that, if you wanna say spigot of capital either coming from the private sector or from the government, that it’s almost like no matter what, there’s going to be spending on AI. So you might as well get allocated to that sector, either directly in the tech names themselves and say, I think Google is going to outdo Microsoft, is going to outdo Anthropic. Or do you want to go downstream and say, listen, I know these guys are going to need raw materials to build a data center or to electrify their plants, and then maybe go towards the miners or the commodities? Where do you think about this AI, if you want to say wartime spending, and where that capital flows to?
Tavi Costa
I think first of all, there’s a private side and a public side, and also there’s how to express this view in the market. I think there is perhaps a conventional thinking out there of how the AI developments are just going to stop. I don’t believe in that at all. I think that’s not the case. The AI spending is— sure, we can see deceleration, that cycle, that’s fine. That’s, you know, that’s part of the game. But to say that we’re not going to go from A to B and the B is going to be much higher, I think that’s crazy. Absolutely crazy. Call And now the question becomes, where do we invest?
That’s an even more relevant way of approaching this. And tech is a sector that everyone is looking at. There’s plenty of capital in it. Tech sector is now, as everybody knows, the largest sector we have in the economy. It is extremely crowded. Valuations are high. It becomes really difficult to find an edge. What I said about mining, about mispriced opportunities, is because there’s a lack of people looking at it, and therefore creates those differences. And the tech space is completely different. I believe myself, I have zero edge to invest in the tech space. And so why am I going to spend time there?
I think there’s a few groups that have that significant edge over that sector. I want to be that in mining, right? Like, I want to be that in hard assets and/or emerging markets. And I think I am that. So I will be playing in the areas that I think my expertise and experience will help me to succeed. And so I believe that this AI idea, the AI trade overall is, you know, think of a pillar where you have technology companies on one side with opportunities to leverage up their balance sheets. Like, I think it’s very misunderstood that the technology space is not levered enough. They could leverage, you know, their balance sheets way more than what they have.
What we’ve seen so far is the squeeze of the spending has caused their free cash flow to be reduced. In some cases, that turned to negative. In some other cases, it’s not quite negative, but overall, as a sector, their free cash flow has been diminished. And because of that, we’ve seen multiples being compressed as well because of the free cash flow decline. And I think the people that invest in the tech sector are making a bet that free cash flow will expand again. And I think that’s unlikely in my opinion. And so I’m very skeptical about that sector.
However, I also know that their situation is kind of like very threatening for their businesses, and they’re likely to continue to spend private or public capital. And I believe that if that continues, that money flows in other areas. It falls into infrastructure, it falls into materials, it falls into banking. All sorts of industries and sectors are going to benefit from this. I like to invest in things that are in the material side of it, or mostly metals in that case. I think energy is also going to be be a big area for investing that capital. Think of that flowing out of tech into those areas, rotating, transitioning, whatever you want to call it. And that’s happening already.
And I think it’s going to happen a lot more. It will accelerate over time, and we’re going to see a shift of multiples where multiples in these parts of the market will expand and the technology multiples are likely to compress. So I’m not making so much of a bet on the tech side, meaning I’m not shorting, I’m not doing anything there, but I’m making a bet that the material side of it will become more And I like my odds. That’s all I’m going to say. I mean, I don’t know. I don’t have a crystal ball like anybody watching here. Nobody has a crystal ball.
But today, the mining industry being 1% of the entire global equity market when it had been in the past 12%, 15%. And do I think we go from 1% to 0%? I don’t think so. Do I think we go from 1% to 15% to 12%? I don’t know, but I think it’s multiples from here. And so if it’s multiples from here versus going from 1% to 0%, I call that asymmetry. Not just me, but anybody with a brain would call that asymmetry. And to me, that’s very attractive, and I can make multiple cases of why that’s going to rise, not fall.
And so either for other reasons, maybe central banks will buy gold and other sovereign wealth institutions will buy resources and other things. And maybe it’s not just the AI idea. You start mixing that with the monetary aspect, you know, all these central banks that need to buy gold to enhance their balance sheets. A good investor looks for a lot of optionality for their theme to play out. And I think there’s no shortage of optionality in the mining industry today.
Why countries want to source critical resources closer to home
Monetary Metals
I want to ask you about one of those different options. So obviously, we’ve talked about AI. If it booms, you know, there might be this need for materials and resources. If it busts, capital might leave the tech and AI trade and go into harder assets. Of course, if there’s, you know, monetary or geopolitical instability, that might lead towards the monetary metals, for example.
What do you think about this idea of deglobalization or onshoring? How important is that to the mining sector, this idea that countries say, you know what, it used to be that a mine in Ecuador and a mine in Canada were basically the same thing. It’s just silver coming out of the ground. But today people say, you know what, we want mining closer to our jurisdiction or closer to our geography. How important is that for investors who are interested in this mining and resource space?
Tavi Costa
Yeah, no, I think it’s extremely important. When I first got involved with mining, one of the main themes was deglobalization. It was the fact that we were going to see a lot of rebuilding. If you think about back back in the early 2000s, what carried on the resource space was really China. It was China purchasing commodities to build their own country and become the manufacturing plant of the global economy. And now it’s not China, it’s the G7 economy, or you can expand to the G20 economy where every country needs to rebuild their facilities.
And forget about AI, just think about manufacturing, think about industries, and think about reducing reliance with China. That’s happening. And that to me was a thesis from years ago. It is playing out in my opinion. And now AI just adds to that, right? So I could have made the case about, you know, the optionality for mining to play out successfully in the next few years or next decade just on the deglobalization front. And now AI just adds another dynamic to this. And as an investor, you kind of pay attention to those factors that change your thesis. And this one certainly does in a very big way.
How global resource demand could shape Latin American politics
Tavi Costa
I think that also it brings attention to Latin America. There are some setbacks, as we are seeing here recently with a few countries and situations. However, the big theme is that the US is looking to source a lot of their materials much closer, as you just mentioned, and I think Latin America would be that strategic region over time. Yes, when you get a country turning left or staying left in that sense, and be mindful that when we say left, parties, left-wing parties in South America or Latin America, they are not your Democrat in the US. We’re talking a lot more left, right?
Like we’re talking way down the spectrum in that side of things. And so I’m from Brazil, lived there part of the year, and I’m aware that that’s the case. However, what people sometimes not appreciate is when you have this sort of structural demand from big countries coming to looking for resources, which is the case with the US specifically and Europe as And even China in South America, Latin America, what you tend to see is that those countries will acknowledge the opportunity eventually, right or left, they will acknowledge the opportunity and start, you know, becoming more pro-mining or pro-energy and so forth.
As we see that occurring, I think a lot of these industries and those countries are going to grow substantially. And so, yes, I pay attention to politics. I pay attention to those changes. They do have leverage, add leverage up or down to those ideas over time. But the foundation of the thesis is much more involved with the demand for resources. You don’t want to be investing in Latin America when you’re at the peak of a commodity cycle. You do not want to be part of that.
That’s when you see nationalization. That’s when you see total collapse of emerging market economies. Currencies tend to be extremely unstable. That’s not what we’re seeing. You know, sure, there’s always going to be volatility. There always going to be corruption, but that doesn’t mean the opportunity is not there either. Brazil was extremely corrupt in the early 2000s, and still the Brazilian Ibovespa index went up 18x under Lula’s leadership.
Okay, I’m going to repeat that, under Lula’s leadership, right? And so does that mean Lula is a great president that will make the country grow by 18x? No, that does not mean that. It means that there’s a foundational thesis That is much more important than political leadership in a lot of ways. And so what happened in Venezuela happened under a regime of a commodities bear market, not a bull market. I really caution people to think about this in a bigger sense when it comes to that. A lot of people disagree with me on this, and that’s absolutely fine. That’s why the opportunity is here.
When people start agreeing with you in the future is exactly when you should not be investing in those things. The fact that people disagree with me that this is a mid-cycle correction in mining, is a great sign. It’s not a bad sign when people comment on videos like this and say that you’re wrong and blah, blah, blah. That’s great. It’s an incredible sign that your thesis is yet to play out and not the other way around. So thanks for those comments. I think it’s always appreciated.
Why Tavi thinks the U.S. dollar is overvalued
Monetary Metals
Well, we have a great comment section at the Gold Exchange Podcast. Make sure to leave a comment for me and Tavi. All right, Tavi, I want to ask you, you’ve basically mentioned this idea that there are these foundational, if you want to say, headwinds, or on the other side, tailwinds that are just so strong that, yes, it might be the case that Lula wins and maybe the conservatives lose, or the balance of power slightly shifts, but there’s a tidal wave, and it doesn’t matter if your boat is 15 feet or 20 feet because you’re on a tidal wave. And so what are some of these other tidal waves?
Obviously, we’ve talked about friendshoring, onshoring, nearshoring. We’ve obviously talked about the AI trade. What about some of the monetary shifts or the fiscal shifts that you’re seeing, because you’ve discussed that as well, you know, the strength of the dollar and of course the power of the Fed. How important are those tidal shifts? Are we right now in a place where, okay, if the Fed raises rates by 25 basis points, it doesn’t really matter because structurally we’re in a kind of different, if you want to say, fiscal or debt regime?
Tavi Costa
Yeah, look, I’ve been of the view that there’s going to be 2 defining factors for the global economy in particular for the next 5 to 10 years. I’m not trying to You know, when you’re trying to figure out, again, foundational macro themes, you’re not looking for a week ahead or 2 weeks ahead. You’re always looking 5, 10 years out. And I just believe very strongly that the US economy cannot sustain such a strong dollar. Like, if you just look at the US dollar today, it’s extremely overvalued and also overbought. And That does not mean, and then people take the other extreme side of it and start saying, do you mean that the dollar is not going to exist?
And we’re, you know, this is the end. Those are scenarios that could play out, but that’s an extreme. That’s, you know, that’s not the foundational. Foundational is much more likely the US dollar will weaken over time. We’ve seen this throughout history multiple times where the DXY index or the broader dollar versus other currencies index goes from you know, 5 to 10-year cycle of upward movement and downward movement.
And I think we’re going to see a downward movement. And when the dollar makes those shifts, you tend to see— and if you take those big indices that measure the dollar versus other fiat currencies, not versus hard assets, what you’re going to see is you take a 10-year rolling change, really big macro cycle kind of research. What you’re going to find is that there are some really long-term cycles in the dollar that are very clear. And we’re at the beginning of one, most likely, where the dollar just started to actually dip on the negative side when it comes to the 10-year rolling change of the DXY index, for instance.
And as we get into this, the big question is, why does the DXY need to be in a downward trend for the next 10 years? And the big reason for that is because the US has 2 problems, right? It has a deficit problem on the fiscal side. In other words, we’re spending more than what we collect in taxes. And the other side of it is the fact that we are also importing way more than what we export.
Now, your dollar bulls would say, you know, but the US has to import more than export because we provide dollars to the world. That’s not the argument here, right? The argument is that our deficit is just too extreme. So the trade balance deficit is too extreme. We can still provide dollars to the world, We can still run a deficit, just not such a pronounced deficit. And that shift of deficit, it’s very difficult to make using long-term approaches. What are the long-term approaches? I’ll give a few examples. Onshoring, it’s a long-term approach.
Trying to build, rebuild the infrastructure here takes a long time. And for that to take place, we’re talking 5, 10 years from now to see that actually Effectively shifting how trade negotiations happen. The other thing that could happen is tariffs and trade negotiations that could change. Those are more kind of your 3 to 5-year shifts. You can’t just tell a company you cannot export or import from this certain country. It takes them time logistically to shift. And so, you know, as we see those things taking place, that’s kind of your big macro play over time.
Now, what could happen in the near term, call it 1 to 3 years, is simply the dollar devaluing versus the Canadian dollar or the dollar devaluing versus the Japanese yen, which has been happening. So these are all countries that we run deficits with, and to reduce that deficit issue, all we need to do is to make our exports more affordable for those countries to acquire. And the simple mechanism to do that is just weakening the dollar. So it’s just taking a currency policy approach that reduces the purchasing power of the US dollar versus those other fiat currencies.
Now, what people reverse the thesis over time, and I’m always paying attention to the opposing view to mine, and the opposing view would say, are you just saying that the euro is a better currency than the dollar? That’s not what I’m saying, right? That’s not what I said at all. I’m not saying the Canadian dollar is a stronger economy than the US. It’s that the US economy simply cannot sustain a strong dollar policy because the debt balance is such— so problematic right now. That is, to service the debt, now we’re starting to grow the economy at 5% just to service the debt. Those other economies are not facing the same problem.
Some of them have high debt problems, but their interest rate is much lower. Japan is a great example of that. If you look at how much Japan is spending to pay down their debt, despite rise of interest rates that we’re seeing here recently in Japan is still very low. The US is 5.4% of the economy. So, you know, that forces the US to have to lower rates as well, suppress rates at all costs, and also have to weaken the dollar. It’s not a trade-off of which economy is better.
It is better for the US to weaken the dollar gradually, maybe not all at once, although we’ve seen that in the past, the Plaza Accord. We’ve seen that During the 1970s when Nixon devalued the dollar versus the Japanese yen and the German mark. But those are all, again, extreme scenarios that could happen. You know, there is precedent for that. We could see it, but that’s not how you plan these things. You plan these things, okay, what if the dollar gradually weakens versus these other currencies intentionally? Okay? Like, there’s a reason why Bastin is buying the Japanese yen. It’s because he’s going to intentionally look for the dollar to be weaker. And everyone needs to pay attention to that from a big macro thesis overall. And what does that mean to other asset classes as we see that occurring?
Monetary Metals
Don’t believe everything you hear about gold. In our report, How Not to Think About Gold, we challenge 8 of the most common fallacies and misconceptions that surround the gold market, including the relationship between interest rates and gold prices, as well as inflation and gold and what it means for supply and demand. If you’re interested in learning more about how not to think about gold, click the link and we’ll send you a free copy.
How Tavi thinks about gold valuation
Monetary Metals
I want to ask you about how you personally value gold. Do you value gold as an inflation hedge? So you’re always watching the inflation numbers. Do you value gold, hey, it’s just a store of value, it’s a diversifier, so it moves differently than stocks and bonds. So I don’t really know how to value it. I just know it it’s uncorrelated? Do you value it, oh really, when the dollar is doing this, gold is doing that? How do you value gold? And is there a way or a certain indicator or indices that investors should look at when they’re thinking, okay, I see the gold price is at $4,000. Is that low? Is that high? Am I kind of dollar-cost averaging now, or am I throwing lump sums amount of currencies at gold? How do you value gold, and how should investors think about valuing gold?
Tavi Costa
That’s a very good question, and there’s different ways to do that. Now, the hat that we wear as a long-term investor, that’s where the real money is made. And there is a hat that we wear as sort of risk management and trying to avoid the drawdowns in that process of creating a lot of wealth. What is so important about gold and why I wanted to get involved back in the days was it is a legacy industry, but also not just mining, but gold itself, but also the history as currency, as a real currency, or I should say as money. And when you say that, people think, are you We’re going to go back to trading gold bars, and that’s not what we’re going to do.
Very unlikely. It could happen. I’m not saying it couldn’t, but that again, that’s like your extreme scenarios that shouldn’t be even discussed. But it’s the idea that it holds value over time as we see the dilution of money of central banks throughout history, which always happens. And as we see the imbalance that we have globally, it shouldn’t be shocking to see gold at multiples of where it is today.
Okay, this is the long-term play. And now people ask, well, what do you mean by multiples? Well, $20,000, $30,000, it’s not out of the range. And please don’t quote me on this, but I do think that that’s a possibility. Those are possibilities. And when I look at a mining company, I’m always thinking— I’m not planning that that’s going to happen next year, but I wouldn’t be investing in these things if I didn’t have that sort of level of conviction that gold could reach to those levels.
The main reason for it is one calculation. Today, the US Treasury Department, if you look at how many treasuries are outstanding, I’ve done this research and shared this research multiple times, it’s about, let’s just say, $40 trillion, right? Treasury market is about $40 trillion outstanding today. Now, give it or take, maybe $41 trillion or so. How much of that is backed by gold today? It’s about $1 trillion. Okay. So it’s about, you know, 3% or so of the Treasury market is backed by— I should say, that is if we value at the current price.
But if we take this to a period like we saw back in the 1940s or 19— you know, even before that, the Treasury market was essentially, you know, pretty much and almost entirely or 50% or so backed by gold. If we see that today, Easy math would take us to $20 trillion of gold backing. You can get to that $20 trillion. The US Treasury could take the holdings to $20 trillion by 2 ways. They can buy gold or they can revalue gold at that price. I couldn’t care less which one they do. I think we’re going to go there. I don’t know if it’s $20 trillion or $10 trillion, but I don’t think it’s one, right?
It’s the same thing as How much percent do you think that the mining industry will get to? And people want to get hung up on that, like, oh, what is the number? I don’t care. I could not care less. It is multiples from here. And if it’s multiples from here, I’m interested. Now, let’s just say 10 years from now, we’re now at 30% backed by gold. Okay, well, I probably won’t be investing a huge percentage of my net worth in mining.
Why? Because the asymmetry is not the same as it was. So you adjust. Does that mean you’re not investing in mining? No, that’s not what I said. So you adjust your portfolio accordingly. Near-term, gold can get overbought, you know, at times and others. And why do I always stay invested? Because we can see a crazy day where Destin announces we’re buying gold and your mining portfolio is going to see a jump that we’ll never see before. And, you know, that could happen tomorrow. You never know. And people that say that that couldn’t happen are just Either naive or just not thinking through it. So I always hold a position, and that’s one way to think about it. Now, I do also try to portfolio manage these things and hold more cash, less cash, and whatever that you want to call that process.
Is this a correction or the end of the cycle?
Tavi Costa
And now I would say that at this sort of $4,000 to $3,800 range, it’s an accumulation phase for gold. I mean, this is one of the best mid-cycle windows I think we will see. And if we go down $3,500, which I think it’s unlikely, it would be a steal. But I don’t think that’s going to happen either. So I think that this environment is extremely supportive to be accumulating shares and launching a fund or something. And again, it’s just my opinion.
And for those that disagree, stay on the sidelines. I mean, you know, it is, you know, every person has to make their own decision here. But I do think that you don’t get bearish on gold after it’s down 30%. Right? Like, if you believe that gold could be multiples from here and gold is down 30%, you know, you take advantage of that. So that’s how I approach this.
What stock-to-flow tells you about gold
Monetary Metals
I want to ask you, how important is the stock-to-flow ratio when you’re thinking about these different commodities? So gold has this incredible stock-to-flow ratio. There’s literally thousands and thousands of years of gold being accumulated. It doesn’t rot, people don’t throw it away, it’s just sitting there in jewelry and bars and coins. waiting to become new supply versus something like plutonium or copper or platinum. People use it up, it gets used in a catalytic converter, it might become wiring, and then we throw it out after a certain point, or it rusts or corrodes. How important is it to think about, well, I’m investing in something that has a high stock-to-flow ratio versus a low stock-to-flow ratio? Does that matter when you’re thinking about, okay, we’re in a commodity cycle, but gold and precious metals are maybe different than the other types of metals?
Tavi Costa
I pay attention to that. I think that the best way to think about it is obviously the thinking of that analysis is the supply and demand imbalance, but also the new supply that gets added to this. People try to complicate things in a lot of ways, right? Like nowadays, the biggest issue we see with Wall Street is that they’re all excited about critical metals, but they don’t want to touch gold, silver, or copper. They want to touch tungsten, you know, rare earth or whatever. And that just annoys the crap out of me because I know these guys have no idea what they’re doing and they’re just investing in, you know, the next flavor of the day.
Like, you remember lithium not too long ago. And I caution people that because it’s like, these people are just clueless about the industry. You know, we’re championing companies taking equity investments from the government. Like, becoming a state-owned company is a good thing now? Like, what? And then you got a blue sweep and then everyone everyone’s like, oh crap, you know, now we got a 15% stake from the government and maybe we’re going to be governed a little bit different than what we thought it was, you know, a year ago. And so wild to me that we’re doing this. And so to me, if you want to keep it simple, to your question about an analytical way of thinking about supply and demand and all that, I think gold, silver, and copper are your simplest ways of investing in the space.
You have some others that will become also very relevant here, which is zinc and nickel are probably your other 2 options. Manganese is our other option as well. Outside of that, it becomes really a little bit outside of the economics of actually making money on mining or also understanding the supply and demand of these resources. Because as we see money pouring in, what we’re now seeing is that you got this kind of unique metals in some cases that are receiving so much capital from Wall Street right now that they don’t need all that capital.
Like rare earth is a great example of that. Too much capital chasing these things. Like nobody said we need all this capital to get rare earth. Okay, it’s critical. Okay, it’s important. Like plenty of capital there now. Like there’s no need for another institution to pour, you know, some of these companies are now worth $10 billion and it’s like, how in the world they’re going to justify the economics of a $10 billion market cap. Like, it’s almost like a massive short, in my opinion.
So I don’t know, I’m a little afraid of all that personally. But yeah, I think there’s going to be a lot of opportunities here, but I don’t want to be overthinking about how to look for allocation in metals and others. I think those are the places to be. Energy is a little bit different. Maybe that’s a whole different discussion. But in metals, I think you don’t need to complicate. Just stay in those names and you’ll be fine. And people like to say, well, when I usually post a chart about silver or something and about how silver is cheap and all that.
Well, it’s because you haven’t seen platinum. Oh, it’s because you haven’t seen palladium. So good luck to everybody there. I think you’re always coming from ideas that have plenty of research that can be backed for and not just looking to your high beta version of gold. Like people that do that usually don’t end up with real wealth. And that’s, eventually the market will cut with you as well.
Rapid-fire questions
Monetary Metals
Yeah, there’s, there’s a reason gold has been seen as wealth for 5,000 years and not plutonium. All right, Tavi, let’s get into a rapid-fire round. I’m going to ask you questions from all over the map. You can answer as short as you want or as long as you want. Let’s start with our first rapid-fire question. In your opinion, who will outperform over the next 5 years, gold or silver?
Tavi Costa
5 is tough. Oh my gosh, because silver doesn’t last that long for a big run. If I would say 2 years, I would confidently take the silver side. I think silver across the metals would be one of the most important opportunities of the next 12 to 24 months. And so that’s kind of how I’m thinking here.
Monetary Metals
All right, next question for you in the rapid-fire section. How can someone decide when they should move some of their portfolio from physical gold into miners and then vice versa from miners back into physical gold?
Tavi Costa
Well, I think it’s a good question. One, it depends on risk profile, but assuming a risk profile that is high, in other words, a person that likes to take risks and doesn’t mind that, I think that you’re always paying attention to the cycle overall. There’s going to be moments where you want to take operational leverage, which is why you buy mining companies. And I’m not saying leverage in the sense of taking debt to buy companies, but rather Just thinking from the standpoint of buying operational leverage as a business, I think today, given how much mining stocks have declined, you want to be taking that aggressiveness to another level right now.
You know, in January, you probably, in hindsight, obviously, that is always easy. You probably could have done the opposite, but in fact, even hold cash. But there’s no shame in holding cash. I think it really depends on how stretched the cycles are. The business cycle for mining is very different than others and metals in general. The mid-cycle corrections can be brutal, and after being through one right now, I think you want to be having a heavier allocation into operational leverage. So that’s kind of how I would pay attention to is how has the performance been here recently? Are we still in a macro long-term cycle. If that’s the case and the performance has been very poor and you’re able to buy shares at cheap levels like today, I think you want to be taking that approach.
Monetary Metals
Okay, next one for you. Which do you think is going to be the biggest headwind for mining companies in 2027? I’ll give you 4 options. Option number 1 is going to be higher than expected inflation. Option number 2 is going to be interest rates being higher than expected. Option number 3 is going to be oil prices being higher than expected. And option number 4 is nope, it’s none of those 3, it’s something else.
Tavi Costa
Look, in our fund, we’re investing in a drilling company right now. It’s one position that we have, and the main reason is because I think ASIC is going to go higher. All-in sustaining cost is going to have to go higher. Metal prices will still be, in my view, rebounding as well, and therefore it will, you know, be okay for these mining companies where we’re not necessarily going to see on a net basis a major squeeze. But yeah, I would expect that the all-in sustaining costs will go up, and mostly because of the cost of operation overall that is related to not just labor, drilling costs, and other things.
With most miners really cashed up, it is very likely that these companies will be okay paying up to expand their businesses, and ASICs should be the biggest factor. I think interest rates and oil are much less likely. And just, you know, full disclosure, 12 months ago, our largest mine in— well, some people know that I am a founding shareholder of St. Cristóbal, which is the largest silver mine in the world today. We hedged our diesel costs 3 years out, 12 months away before all this stuff that happened with the war, just because of how dislocated the silver market was relative to diesel. And would I take the same bet today?
No, I would not. I think this is not the time to be adding hedges on that side of things. But some people disagree with me. Again, the market has come to meet, so a lot of people will say you’re wrong because, you know, they’re agreeing with what I said 12 months ago. And it is what it is. I already moved on. So yeah.
Monetary Metals
All right, next rapid-fire question for you. Which do you think is going to happen first? The gold price will hit $3,000 or the gold price will hit $5,000?
Tavi Costa
$5,000.
Monetary Metals
Okay, next question for you. The same with silver. Which do you think is more likely? Silver price to hit $10 first or $100 first? $100. Alrighty, now here’s a fun one for you. The Federal Reserve is most likely in its next meeting to stay, cut, or raise rates?
Tavi Costa
Tough one. Oh, this is very tough. I’m going to go for— I think these guys are going to hike because of the labor market data that came out these last days as well. It’s hard, you know, because you’re not giving me odds. I like to take the hold, Because of the odds. But if you’re not giving me odds, I would be stupid not to say hike because that’s, you know, that’s the higher probability. So,
Monetary Metals
hey, nothing more fun as a host making your guests squirm. All right, here’s the next rapid-fire question for you. Let’s talk about inflation. Do you think inflation over the long term is always going to be above the Fed rate? Are we basically in a sticky inflation environment where we can’t get it under 2%? Or do you think, ta-da, Kevin Warsh is a magician and we inflation under 2%? No,
Tavi Costa
I don’t think it’s going to get under 2% at all unless we see a major economic issue that doesn’t— that is not met with liquidity. And I don’t think that’s going to be the case. So yeah. All
Monetary Metals
right, next rapid-fire question for you. What assets outside of currencies and gold do you think that central banks would add to their reserves next?
Tavi Costa
Silver. I’ll go with silver and maybe copper.
Monetary Metals
All right. Next one for you. What do you think about this idea of tokenizing commodities, tokenizing gold, tokenizing mining companies? Do you think this is just a fad that soon people are going to be like, why did we even end up doing that? Or is this the new way to, if you want to say, expand the market for the commodities sector?
Tavi Costa
I’ll be extremely honest to you. I don’t understand much of the case for it outside of making it simpler logistically and also to also make it simpler operationally. Can we transition to that world? Probably, but I don’t think it adds new liquidity. Like, I think that’s just not true, but hey, maybe I’m wrong. I would love a world that we can account for things easier and better. If tokenizing is that, that would be wonderful. Like, for instance, you know, like we have today, no markets in a lot of ways for some minerals that are sold by mining companies.
They have to rely on offtake businesses that a lot of times are taking advantage of these companies. And I don’t mean it in a bad way. The contrary to that is that they wouldn’t add anything to their revenue. But if there was a market out there, there wouldn’t be much room for these offtake businesses to, you know, to make money on these things either. So I think that over time we should transition to that, and I think that would be a good thing. Now, do I think that tokenizing adds a new liquid— I think that’s all. I don’t believe in that at all. I don’t think it’s going to add new liquidity.
Monetary Metals
I want to ask you about our friends, the BRICS countries. That’s Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa. If you had to give me an overperformer and underperformer of that BRICS group, who would you give me?
Tavi Costa
Brazil probably is my top choice right now. China’s so cheap that it’s tough to bet against it now. But in how many years do you think?
Monetary Metals
Let’s give you a 5-year time horizon.
Tavi Costa
I’ll go Brazil.
Monetary Metals
Okay, next question for you, which is about emerging market equities versus US market equities. What is the factor that you watch to decide, I think emerging markets are going to outperform versus the US is going to outperform?
Tavi Costa
Very simple. Interest rates and the dollar. Yeah, both are the most important things. I mean, you don’t want to invest in emerging markets if you think it’s going to be a stronger dollar and higher rates. That kills emerging markets sustainably, right? Not a hike. I’m talking sustainably. So those 2 things.
Monetary Metals
All right. Next in the rapid-fire section, of course, we talked about tokenized commodities, but of course there’s these US dollar stablecoins which have had quite a bit of dispersion in Latin America, Africa, and the rest of the world, and that’s hurt the local currencies of those economies. Which local currency do you think is most likely to kick the bucket next?
Tavi Costa
I don’t have an opinion there. I wish I had something to say, but I don’t.
Monetary Metals
All right, next rapid-fire question for you. What’s an economic indicator that you think investors pay too much attention to?
Tavi Costa
PPI. It’s just so stupid. We all know it’s fake, but markets react to it. So yeah, it’s wild to me, but I’m not here to make the rules. I’m here to play the game.
Monetary Metals
All right, next one for you. What is your highest conviction trade for 2027?
Tavi Costa
It’s miners right now, for sure, particularly silver miners. But miners look extremely compelling. You can take gold too if you’re risk-averse. But yeah, I think it’s very, very
Monetary Metals
All right, Tavi, last rapid-fire question for you. What’s the best gift that you’ve ever received?
Tavi Costa
My daughters.
Monetary Metals
Good answer. All right, as we exit this rapid-fire section, I want to ask you a question I ask all the guests of the Gold Exchange Podcast, you included, which is, what’s a question I should be asking all future guests of the Gold Exchange Podcast?
Tavi Costa
Most assets would be tied up to US dollar and rates. And what I mean rates is usually 10-year yield, just to simplify the answer. I think knowing the direction of the DXY index and US interest rates, 10-year yields for the next 5 to 10 years is absolutely critical to, you know, like a lot of people say strong dollar, what does that mean? Or weak dollar, what does that mean? Ask that targeted question about the instrument. Use an instrument for that and timestamp that because I think that is extremely relevant for other assets as asset classes. If you have a view on those 2, you have a view in emerging markets, you probably have a view on Metals, you probably have a view on miners, resources, energy, and other things. And so I would try to get those 2 things very, very clear.
Monetary Metals
Tavi, as always, it is a pleasure having you on. If people want to hear more Tavi Costa, and of course if they want to be invested in Azuria Capital, where can they find you?
Tavi Costa
You can find me at X @TaviCosta. They can find me on Substack to learn more about ideas, and also they can email me at [email protected]. So always happy to share more. Azuriacapital.com is also a website, so you can go there too.
Monetary Metals
All right, Tavi, as always, it’s a pleasure. We’ll have to have you on again soon. Thanks so much for joining us again.
Tavi Costa
Thanks for having me.